
I’d never written a play before I wrote As the Sun Sets. Well, one, as a very naïve and unskilled nineteen year old. It was a terrible rip-off of Tarantino, or maybe Scorsese, entitled And the City Rats Screamed. Hardly a homage, barely a fan-fic. A misguided attempt to write a movie I’d not seen yet. It was consigned to, and will remain in, the File Where Bad Writing Goes to Die. Officially, As the Sun Sets was my first proper play.
The opportunity provided to me by the Wellington team Magnificent Weirdos was almost too good to be true. An experience to not only have my play performed on stage in my home city, but to also gain valuable feedback via workshops and group read-throughs. I really can’t express how grateful I am for the chance, and for everything I learned in the process.
At the end of each performance, each writer was invited to kōrero (have a conversation) with a live audience to answer questions and talk about the play. I was absolutely terrified of being on stage, but it was a deeply rewarding experience. The support I received for my disability (severe Deafness) was exceptional, and it helped me realise that with the right accessibility supports, my Deafness didn’t need to be a barrier to me doing things in the way I believed it was. That was a real gamechanger for me.
I wrote this blog post as a continuation of that kōrero, and to share a bit more about my writing process and the story behind the play. You can read the full play here, and I suggest you do, or much of this post won’t make much sense!
The seeds for As the Sun Sets began in a graveyard, not unlike the one featured in the story. I was slowly coming out of a self-imposed bubble, a place I had retreated to lick my wounds after a time of trauma, and begin rebuilding who I was as a writer. I began taking silly little walks for my silly little mental health, and the graveyard, with its accompanying church, became one of my favourite places to go. It was an ideal mid-point in my walk where I could sit, and just be quiet for a while. I never went inside the church, that wasn’t the purpose for my visits. No, I was only interested in the graveyard itself, filled with the headstones of pioneers long past, rarely visited by anyone else, yet still beautifully and lovingly tended to. I would sit on a bench overlooking it all and feel grounded and at peace. It was one of the very few places outside of my home bubble where I felt safe and unbothered. Where I could relax and think.

My favoured bench sported a plaque in memory of Cliff and Alma Gardener, church and graveyard minders for over fifty years. It didn’t matter to me who they really were, in my head they were also my unseen minders. One afternoon, as the sun was slipping down behind the hills and the shadows around me grew longer, I stood to leave, and without knowing why, I patted the bench and said, “thank you for sharing your bench with me Cliff and Alma.” It was a silly gesture, done without any real thought or meaning, but it sowed an idea in my head as I walked home. The main character, known only as M, became clear to me, I could almost see her there on the bench, her head bowed and her posture sad. She spoke softly, spilling her secrets to some unseen audience. Confiding in two people who were not really there, but were somehow more real to her than her own friends and family.
The graveyard was a safe space for me to think and take some time away from all the chaos in my life. To connect with nature, to watch the birds and breathe fresh air. It made sense to me that others might also find it such a powerful place.
The next day, I began writing.
When I began, I liked M. I thought she was someone who had experienced an awful lot of trauma and heartache. She needed guidance, support and love. By the end, I didn’t like her much at all. Even though I understood her motivations, what drove her to make the choices she did, I couldn’t respect her, or understand why she didn’t find better ways to process that trauma. In many ways, I had thought I was writing a version of myself, but I found out she was the complete opposite. I don’t even really know who I based her on in the end. She was an extremely interesting character to explore, especially the relationships she had with those around her.
Initial feedback to my first draft was to give her a more rounded backstory, some explanations for her behaviour, as well as building a stronger idea of who she was. This was easy to do, as I’d already mapped out a much longer story before I settled on the monologue format. Although, in some ways this also made it harder as I had so many ideas I wasn’t sure what to cut and what to keep. The Magnificent Weirdos team did a fantastic job of guiding me to create a more streamlined story, and to fix some glaring plot holes! Also, seeing how other people interacted with my words and characters was incredibly educational and emotional for me. As a writer, it’s not something I get to experience often. Once the words are written and sent into the world, it’s rare that I get any first-hand feedback on how the reader has interacted with them.
The play explores themes of family, grief, illness and generational trauma. Trying to pack all of that into a twenty minute monologue was quite a challenge. I know that once I expand the story into a novella (which I’m working on right now!) I’ll be able to tackle them all in more depth. M feels to me like someone who does not really know how to be an adult. A chid still trapped in an aging, unwell body with no tools to navigate the real world. Most of this comes from her upbringing, and her relationship with her Nana, but I also feel like it’s a choice for her to never attempt real growth. Her obsession with fantasy worlds keeps her stuck from moving on in her own. She longs to be transported to another time and place where she does not have to address her responsibilities. I think this is why she chooses to do what she does at the end. The gut-punch to the audience, who perhaps believed she would make amends somehow and act better than those who hurt her, is that realisation that maybe she’s not such a nice person after all. She acts only in self-preservation. Terrified that her family will find out her long-kept secret, she does everything she can to bury it even deeper.
M’s conversations with Robert and Edith are one-sided. They have no opportunity to tell her what they really think, or guide her actions. While in her head they are no doubt surrogates for the parents she has lost, they will never contradict her or tell her when she is wrong. Perhaps this is the biggest problem for M in that she should be confiding in people who can give her that feedback, her actual family. I suspect that one of the reasons she doesn’t, is because deep down she knows they will be appalled by her actions. While Nana was clearly an awful influence in her life, we also only know what M chooses to tell us. She appears honest and open, but is actually an unreliable narrator. She speaks of loving her family, but it seems like that love is past-tense. The only person she really speaks fondly of is her young grandson, Henry, who mirrors her need for authenticity and freedom. Henry runs barefoot in the garden and chases butterflies in the sun. He is never admonished for this, in fact it is encouraged. He reminds her of the child she wanted to be but was never allowed. Her own childhood is filled with misery and abuse, and she has carried that with her into adulthood. I don’t even believe her marriage to John was based on romance, merely a desire to escape and start anew.
The novella will explore all of these ideas in more depths, and who knows, maybe I will find a way to like M again. Maybe she is not completely lost, and will redeem herself somehow. Perhaps the full story is not hers alone, but that of her abandoned child, Ezekiel. I have a plan, but as with all my stories, often the characters have other ideas. I just know it is going to be fun to write. And despite her faults, I will always look back on M, with fondness, for without her I would still be stuck in a bubble, licking my wounds and wondering who I was as a writer.

Thank you also, Cliff and Alma, whoever you are, or were. Your bench will always remain one of my favourite places to sit and be quiet for a while.